Coffee Spice Cake

What the Heck is Coffee Milk Syrup?

I’m as lost as you! I’ve never heard of the thing, never knew it existed, and had no idea how it was made or why anyone would want to use this product.

I’m a coffee drinker so I can appreciate a good coffee flavored ice cream, coffee flavored whatever and I’ll be all over that, but when Baker Batch told me I’d be working with Dave’s Coffee Milk Syrup to bring ya’ll something creative I was excited and…concerned. I had no idea how to use it!

Until, like any good librarian, I did my research and found that this product is not only a Rhode Island staple, it’s also used primarily in milk.

Well, how is it made?

“It all starts with our fresh roasted coffee. We’ve selected a superb Brazilian bean and roasted it specifically to be used in our coffee syrup. It’s nutty, sweet, smooth and roasted with it’s natural smokey goodness. The finished roast then rests for two days.

After resting the coffee is ground and cold brewed for 18 hours in our modified stainless steel kettle.

Finally, the cold brewed coffee is drained and combined with pure cane sugar. The mixture of coffee and sugar is brought to a boil and simmers for over an hour. During this time the syrup reduces and the sugar begins to caramelize. When the syrup reaches the perfect consistency, it is hot bottled into our signature amber glass bottles. The amber glass protects the sweet flavor of our coffee syrup from the environment.

There’s a whole lot of love that goes into each bottle of Dave’s Coffee Syrup. And, from the roasted coffee to the bottled syrup, we do it all right here in Rhode Island. “ – Dave’s Coffee

I blame all my Rhode Island friends for not introducing me to this gem earlier, but I’m sure glad that I had the chance to work with Dave’s Coffee Milk Syrup now!





  • 1/2 cup unsalted butter
  • 1 cup white sugar
  • 1 egg
  • 1/4 cup Dave’s Coffee Milk Syrup
  • 1/2 cup almond milk
  • 2 cups sifted flour
  • 1/2 tsp. salt
  • 1/2 tsp. cinnamon
  • 1/2 tsp. nutmeg
  • 2 tsp. baking powder


Cream unsalted butter.

Add sugar and thoroughly mix.

Beat in 1 egg.

Add mixture of coffee syrup and milk.

Sift dry ingredients into others and beat for 1 minute. Sifting the flour is very important. If you don’t sift the flour the cake will be very dense.

Bakers Tip: Drizzle some coffee syrup on each slice to give it some moisture! And if you don’t have a bundt pan do not worry! Any pan will work just keep your eyes on the bake.



Baker's Batch

Baker’s Batch is a community focused on empowering up and coming baker’s and indie brands. We want to help you discover the best recipes, stories and products and help bakers and brands to grow their business.

No Comments Yet

Comments are closed